Friday 19 September
  • Common activities
    • 19 September 2008, 09:00-11:45

      Plenary Session 5

      This session contains a keynote speech from Maren Jochimsen and speeches from Ulrike Röhr and Gotelind Alber. Go to Plenary Session 5 for abstracts and titles.

      Contributors

      Elvira Sch, chair of session(email)

      Location

      Siegbahn Hall

      Campusmap

    • 19 September 2008, 10:00-10:30

      Coffee and Book table

      Coffee and Book table take place in the conference foyer.

      Location

      Symposium lobby

      The symposium lobby is located outside of room 7-0042 and 7-0043 in house 7 at Campus English Park. Enter the building through the main glass entrance. Go to the right and follow signs to the lobby where registration is taking place.

      Map: http://www.engelskaparken.uu.se/Campusinfo/Kvarterskiss/tabid/613/language/sv-SE/Default.aspx

    • 19 September 2008, 11:55-13:00

      Parallell Sessions: Dynamics and NorWiP

      Chair of the session Dynamics: Helene Götschel, member of the Organizing Committee

      This session will be held in room 2002.


      Chair of the session NorWiP: Camille Bélanger-Champagne, member of the Organizing Committee

      This session will be held in room 2003.

       


       

      Contributors

      Helene Göt, chair of session(email)
    • 19 September 2008, 12:45-14:00

      Lunch

      A lunch sandwich is provided in the conference foyer in return for a lunch ticket which you will receive upon registration. 

      Location

      Symposium lobby

      The symposium lobby is located outside of room 7-0042 and 7-0043 in house 7 at Campus English Park. Enter the building through the main glass entrance. Go to the right and follow signs to the lobby where registration is taking place.

      Map: http://www.engelskaparken.uu.se/Campusinfo/Kvarterskiss/tabid/613/language/sv-SE/Default.aspx

    • 19 September 2008, 13:55-14:40

      Plenary Session 6

      This session contains a speech from Monika Bessenrodt-Weberpals. Go to Plenary Session 6 for abstract and title.

      Contributors

      Anna Danielsson, chair of session(email)

      Location

      Siegbahn Hall

      Campusmap

    • 19 September 2008, 14:45-15:30

      Conference Summary

      NorWiP future - actions

      Pysics/Gender Network?

      Conference Chair and NorWiP Board Members

      Location

      Siegbahn Hall

      Campusmap

    • 19 September 2008, 15:30-16:00

      Departure

  • P S: Dynamics
    • 19 September 2008, 12:00-12:20

      Why do Physics Students' Motivational Patterns look like no-one else's?

      At GenDADA aspects of a project will be presented, which identifies typical motivational patterns that drive the strategies and approaches that students take towards studying. The focus will especially be on sharing preliminary results towards explaining why students of mathematics, chemistry and physics, with special attention to the latter, do not fit any, of an array of qualitatively different patterns that otherwise fit cohorts in the humanities, medical sciences and vocationally oriented university programmes at the University of Copenhagen. Some of the variables representing this difference between science students and students in other programmes could very well be uncovered through a gender perspective.
      The presentation will cover the introductory research setup of a PhD project that will be conducted at the Department of Science Education in Copenhagen over the next three years. The project has its origins in studying attrition at Uppsala University, where it was necessary to understand student reasoning and explanation modelled around an ‘introspective’ discourse (Johannsen, 2007). As such, a general reason stated for leaving the physics programme, was that students did not feel that they ‘were meant for studying physics’. Alternatively, one might have expected reasons that concerned the educational setting, concerns that consequently could have been addressed, rather than, as stated above, reasons that appear to only indirectly concern the educational setting.
      Recent pedagogical literature draws a picture of Scandinavian primary and secondary education that actively encourages a form of student learning which evolves around self-relating and actualization (c.f. Frykman, 1998; Ziehe, 2001; Illeris, Katznelson et al., 2002). This pedagogy is didactically well founded in drawing on constructivist and exemplary teaching concepts as well as reflecting a critical democratic perspective on education (Negt, 1971; Wagenschein, 1999). But from the perspective of
      researchers in the field of attrition and retention in tertiary education, the self-relating discourse
      models that students make use of when reflecting on educational expectations, can at times seem informatively poor or even irrelevant, as when students say that “I do not know what I expected, but what the programme offered, was not it.”(Holm, Laursen et al., 2008).
      A reasonably safe hypothesis regarding attrition would be that students who leave tertiary education prematurely do so because of a mismatch between their expectations and the perceived reality of the study environment. As with the example above (ibid) one could easily imagine that a student who was forced out because of low academic achievement is also a student who started studying expecting a different study environment than the one perceived; a study environment that the student expected
      to be motivating to a degree that ensured sufficiently high academic achievement. Getting into detail about such expectations could reveal a valuable student experience. Such experiences could be taken into consideration when planning new educational activities or be used to inform research on attrition. Some students might have unreasonable expectations, while others might not. Nonetheless these expectations have roots in youth culture (incl. prior education, media etc.) and must be addressed if education is to respond to and reflect the expectations that the students who are going to be educated hold.
      What was found in Uppsala was that the students, who were interviewed, reflected on the
      relationship between their perceived naïve expectations and the selves they were actively constructing through education. In effect, they appeared to perceive the institution as a fixed entity towards which expectations needed to be either attuned or matched. What they did not do, was to reflect on their expectations as expectations the institution could or should have met. In addition, one might hypothesize that students do not have an actively conscious idea of what expectations they actually hold, which makes the understanding of attrition even more evasive. To circumvent such issues a group of researchers across faculties at the University of Copenhagen and the Technical University of Denmark have identified an array of qualitatively different types of motivational patterns driving strategies and approaches towards studies. They devised a questionnaire with the intention of using it as an instrument for quantitative readouts of the distribution of students’ motivational patterns at, ideally, each of the tertiary level educational programmes viewed
      separately and in comparison (Damsholt, Boeskov et al., 2003; Damsholt, Horst et al., 2008). Such a quantitative instrument could be useful in a wide array of fields within educational research – especially issues regarding socioculture and gender. When the result of a pilot project testing such a quantitative instrument was analysed, the results showed that all, but students of chemistry, mathematics and physics, captured patterns of motivation in ways that were statistically and qualitatively sound (Damsholt, Horst et al., 2008). For instance, the cohort in nanotechnology and in
      biochemistry respectively, was mostly motivationally oriented towards prospects of future employment, whereas the cohort in medicine and in molecular biology respectively, was mostly oriented towards aspects of status and recognition that follow the professions.
      Importantly, students of chemistry, mathematics and physics did not fit any of the typical
      motivational patterns and were statistically negatively correlated on all the motivational patterns the questionnaire addressed (ibid). Theories that could explain this enigma will be tested in August of 2008 when a new group of students starts studying physics at the University of Copenhagen.
      Preliminary results will be shared.

      Location

      Room 7-0042

    • 19 September 2008, 12:20-12:40

      Dancing equations: the embodiment of physics

      “We all are and we all have a body and therefore it is the best tool to think with.”1
      In western culture, boys and men are encouraged to play with their physical power, and girls and women are encouraged to be docile.  Feminine body comportment is expected to be “restricted, inhibited and confined”2, whereas boys are encouraged to be “physical”.  Boys therefore have the opportunity through play to develop a visceral understanding of force, power, speed and acceleration – definitional concepts in physics.  It is possible that without a physical relationship to physical concepts, girls engage with physics only at a cognitive level. If girls are given the opportunity to ‘embody’ physical concepts, will this aid their understanding?
      When teaching first year engineering physics labs, I wondered whether a dance-based explanation of electromagnetic waves would help my male and female students understand the concepts around light polarization necessary to complete the designed experiments.  I wanted the students to use their bodies to understand equations describing linear and circular polarization of light.  By tracking the vertical component of the equation below (where θ = 0) with their left arm and the horizontal component with their right, the students were able to describe the two perpendicular waves and feel how the sum of their components add to linearly polarized light. 
       
      Then I asked them to dance the result of adding a quarter (θ = π/2) or half-wave (θ = π) phase shift in y.  It was incredible how quickly all students caught onto the concepts once they experienced them in their bodies.   When they added quarter and half-wave plates in front of their lasers during the lab, their questions to me were more sophisticated than I had anticipated.  At times, I had to scribble down equations to make sense of their questions because I had not yet embodied the concepts.
      Girls and women are more likely to dance than engage in other sports3,4.  Rather than relying on sport awareness to teach physical concepts, we might find greater success in dance as a vehicle to learning.  Teaching physics through movement may open up more opportunities for girls and women to “get” physics at a visceral level.

      1. Mauss, M. (2007). Techniques of the Body (excerpt). In M. Lock & J. Farquhar (Eds.), Beyond the Body Proper: Reading the Anthropology of Material Life (pp. 50-68). Durham: Duke University Press. (Original work published 1973 [1935]).
      2. Young, Iris Marion (1990). Throwing Like a Girl and Other Essays in Feminist Philosophy and Social Theory. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.
      3. Children's Participation in Cultural and Leisure Activities, Australia, Apr 2006
      4. http://www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/sgr/pdf/chap5.pdf

      Location

      Room 7-0042

    • 19 September 2008, 12:40-13:00

      Gender in engineering education- students reviewing their education from a gender perspective

      Åsa Kassman Rudolphi, Institutionen för teknikvetenskaper, Uppsala universitet
      Maria Orvehed, Fakultetskansliet Teknisk-naturvetenskapliga fakulteten, Uppsala universitet

      Ett projekt där studenter granskat sin utbildning ur ett genusperspektiv, genomfördes under perioden oktober 2007 till april 2008 vid Uppsala universitet. De utbildningar som ingick i projektet var civilingenjörsprogrammen i teknisk fysik, system i teknik och samhälle, och kemiteknik. Totalt deltog femton studenter från årskurserna två och tre, varav åtta kvinnliga studenter och sju manliga. Studenterna granskade hela studiemiljön: schemalagd undervisning såsom föreläsningar, lektioner, laborationer och seminarier, aktiviteter utanför schemalagd undervisning, lokaler, etc.
      Syftet med granskningen var att få information om kulturen på utbildningarna med målet att upptäcka eventuella strukturer som kan utgöra hinder för kvinnliga studenter, samt få en kunskapsbas för ett förbättringsarbete. Metoden, att utgå från studenternas egna observationer och reflektioner, användes för att garantera ett ”användarfokus”. (Liknande studier har genomförts vid Linköpings universitet  och Karolinska institutet .)

      I denna presentation beskrivs metodik och upplägg av projektet, resultat från studenternas observationer, samt slutsatser och erfarenheter från projektet.
      Projektet inleddes med en utbildningsdag med föreläsningar och diskussioner kring genusteori och granskningsmetodik. Här deltog en expert inom genusmedveten pedagog samt universitetets jämställdhetshandläggare. Under granskningsperioden hölls tre uppföljningsträffar på lunchtid och projektet avslutades med en avslutningsträff under en eftermiddag. Under granskningsperioden förde studenterna anteckningar och i slutet sammanställde de en rapport, som utgjorde underlag för en slutrapport.
      Studenterna har sett prov på både genusmedveten pedagogik och besvärande könsrolls-schabloner bland lärare och handledare. Från föreläsningar och lektioner har granskarna rapporterat om en allmän brist på interaktion och aktiverande pedagogik, vilket i sig inte har ansetts vara genusrelaterat. Laborationer utmärks av att studenterna väljer grupper fritt och då oftast jobbar i könsuppdelade grupper och med samma personer hela tiden. Möjligen får kvinnliga studenter mer hjälp på gott och ont. Studenterna har också observerat, inte överraskande, bristen på kvinnliga förebilder vad gäller föreläsare, lektionsledare, handledare och författare till kurslitteratur.
      Utöver granskningsresultaten har projektet lett till en ökad medvetenhet hos de deltagande studenterna. Ett förslag från de medverkande studenterna är att alla studenter bör få en utbildning i genusteori. De anser dessutom att alla lärare bör utbildas i genusmedveten pedagogik, vilket också finns som en åtgärd i fakultetens jämställdhetsplan. Metoden att använda studenter som utvärderare har fungerat mycket bra, även om de själva har beskrivit vissa svårigheter med att granska det de själva deltar i, och kan prövas inom fler områden.
      Medel till granskningen beviljades från universitetets jämställdhetsutskott. UppsalaTeknolog- och Naturvetarkåren UTN har medverkat och varit drivande i projektet.

      Location

      Room 7-0042

  • P S: NorWiP
    • 19 September 2008, 12:00-12:20

      Neutron emission spectroscopy as a tool for determining fusion plasma conditions

      Maria Gatu Johnson, Uppsala University

      Neutron emission spectroscopy In order to achieve the goal of commercial energy from nuclear fusion, the properties of the fusion
      plasma need to be known, controlled and understood. These properties are studied at experimental reactors around the world today using a plethora of advanced fusion diagnostics.
      Neutrons are produced in both the fusion reaction targeted for future commercial fusion, d+t→α+n, and the main reaction studied in fusion research today, d+d→3He+n. They are an excellent tool for determining the properties of a magnetically confined fusion plasma because they escape the confinement to become indicators on the outside of internal conditions.
      Three main categories of neutron measurements provide different information about the plasma. Neutron counters give integrated or time resolved neutron yields that can be used to deduce the total fusion power produced. Neutron profile monitors give a spatially resolved picture of the neutron emission. Neutron emission spectroscopy (NES) aims at deducing the energy of the emitted
      neutrons. NES can be used to determine the properties of the plasma in terms of fuel ion velocity distributions. From this, the effect of applied heating schemes can be determined. The analysis also yields results on ion temperatures and plasma rotation.
      This contribution will describe neutron measurements as a fusion diagnostic in general, with a focus on NES. The possibilities of the NES tool will be highlighted with recent results from the neutron spectrometers TOFOR and MPRu installed at the main European research reactor JET in Oxford, England.

      Location

      Biotopia Museum

      Vasagatan 4.

      Map: http://kartor.eniro.se/m/pEXW1

    • 19 September 2008, 12:20-12:40

      Search for exotic heavy particles at ATLAS and LHC

      The Large Hadron Collider is a particle accelerator that will start to collide protons at high energies this summer (2008).  The ATLAS detector is designed to measure the properties of the particles created in the collisions, and the hope is to discover new kind of matter. One exotic scenario is the existence of meta-stable, massive particles. Such particles are predicted by many beyond the Standard Model theories and their discovery or non-discovery will indicate how nature is designed on a fundamental level. We have studied a particular group of stable, massive particles containing a supersymmetric quark and investigated the possibilities of discovering such a particle in the ATLAS detector.

      Location

      Biotopia Museum

      Vasagatan 4.

      Map: http://kartor.eniro.se/m/pEXW1

    • 19 September 2008, 12:40-13:00

      The Optical Replica Synthesizer of the FLASH accelerator at DESY

      Gergana Angelova Hamberg, Uppsala University

      Three universities (Uppsala University, Stockholm University and KTH) joined together in the creation of the Free Electron Laser Center in 2006. The biggest (~1M?) and most complex project financed by the center was the installation of the Optical Replica Synthesizer (ORS)-a novel device to diagnose ultra-short electron bunches. ORS was installed during the spring shutdown in 2007 in the FLASH accelerator at DESY, Hamburg and successfully commissioned.  In this talk the author will present her work as a coordinator of the Optical Replica Synthesizer project.

      Location

      Biotopia Museum

      Vasagatan 4.

      Map: http://kartor.eniro.se/m/pEXW1

  • Plenary Session 5
    • 19 September 2008, 09:00-10:00

      Keynote III

      Maren Jochimsen, Secretary General of the European Platform of Women Scientists (EPWS)

      Location

      Siegbahn Hall

      Campusmap

    • 19 September 2008, 10:30-11:05

      Applying Physics at our Service: Climate Change: Why Gender Matters

      Mainstreaming Gender into the International Climate Change Negotiations

      Ulrike Röhr, Head of genanet – focal point gender, environment, sustainability, Berlin

      Unlike most of the United Nations conventions in the last decade, the Framework Convention on Climate Change has failed to adopt a gender-sensitive strategy, nor is it addressing women as stakeholders or persons affected. Same applies to the Kyoto Protocol, a specific agreement to the convention, which was developed to create concrete targets, policies and monitoring mechanisms. The missing link to gender equality in the decisions hampers to call attention to gender impacts of climate change policy, in particular because social aspects in general are marginalized in the UNFCCC and Kyoto Protocol. This failure of integrating gender results in shortcomings in the efficiency and effectiveness of climate related measures and instruments.

      Due to this situation, women’s organizations involvement in the annual Conferences of the Parties (COP) to the UNFCCC was poor in recent years, although there was a promising start during the first COP 1995 in Berlin. After a period of low participation, women’s groups have picked up the strands again since 2002, holding side events, distributing statements, hosting exhibition booths, discussing gender issues with delegations, and convening Women’s Caucuses.

      After some years of persistence and competing for attention, at COP13 in Bali (2007), from a gender perspective a significant breakthrough was achieved. For the first time in UNFCCC history, a world wide network of women, gendercc – women for climate justice, was established. The group published several position papers articulating the women and gender perspectives on the most pressing issues under negotiation. The papers are addressing the Post-Kyoto-Negotiations, financing climate change adaptation and mitigation, prevention of deforestation, agrofuels or nuclear energy from a gender perspective. They are criticizing the uni-dimensional and exclusive focus of the climate change debates to technical and market based solutions to mitigate climate change which don’t apply to sustainable development, and demand of the integration gender analysis in the review and further development of the mechanisms as well as for strong criteria to ensure women’s benefits from funds set up to support adaptation to climate change in developing countries.

      A range of activities on women’s and gender issues was organized during COP13 by various organizations and institutions. And they met with interest, increasing awareness, and increased expression of commitment to gender justice from a number of stakeholders.

      In the future, similar efforts must be undertaken related to the process and institutional arrangements. Continuous representation of women and the gendercc network will be crucial. On the other hand, in order to prepare substantial input into the meetings, it is necessary to link discussions at local levels to those at the international level – feeding local realities and experiences into the general and abstract discussions at the global level, as well as ‘translating’ global changes and international policies so as to communicate what these will, or may, mean for local communities. Providing capacity development opportunities for women and gender activities who are prepared to raise their voices in the international policy arena will be key, so that they can become effective advocates on policy and effective communicators to communities and networks around the world.

      The activities in Bali paved the way for implementing gender mainstreaming into the Post-Kyoto-Negotiations, which are planned to be finalized at COP15 in Copenhagen in December 2009. An intermediate step will be undertaken at the next conference to be held in Poznan in December 2008: the network is planning for a parallel conference aiming to discuss concrete demands and recommendations for the negotiation texts.

      Location

      Siegbahn Hall

      Campusmap

    • 19 September 2008, 11:05-11:45

      Applying Physics at our Service: Climate Change: Why Gender Matters

      The Gender Dimension of Climate Change Policy

      Gotelind Alber, Independent consultant and researcher on sustainable energy and climate policy, Berlin

      Recent European studies on the perceptions of climate change suggest that women consider climate change impacts to be more severe, and  they are more sceptical regarding the effectiveness of current climate policies in solving the problem. Therefore, women usually argue for more effective climate policy, and are more willing to change to a more climate-friendly lifestyle. In contrast, men tend to heir trust in scientific and technical solutions. This suggests that the gender dimension plays a role in climate change policy, and that women would set different priorities for climate protection.

      Moreover, there are strong indications that policies and measures to mitigate, and to adapt to the impacts of climate change, are not gender neutral. For example, given that in the European Union, on average, women earn 15 % less than men, and 27 % of single mothers are living below poverty levels, are these different preconditions taken into account in the design of policies and measures? Are circumstances of caregivers of children and the elderly adequately reflected in the design of climate protection measures? 

      Climate protection policy areas, such as energy, urban development and transport planning tend to be male-dominated. What is the effect on measures and policies if they are planned from the viewpoint of one gender? There are strong indications that e.g. urban and transport planning are biased towards employed citizens, neglecting the needs of citizens who take care for reproductive work or seek to combine reproductive and employed work. Moreover, financial incentives for sustainable energy options favour those who are better-off anyway. Information and communication on climate change impacts and policies relates to the traditional roles of women and men, instead of contributing to overcoming these roles.

      In the area of adaptation (adjusting to the impacts of climate change), the gender dimension is even more evident. Vulnerability (to the impacts of climate change) is not defined by natural, but rather by social conditions. Poor people, with 70% of them estimated to be women, are more affected by climate variations and extreme weather events than the well-off.

      Thus, climate policies and measures which do not take into account gender aspects, may unintentionally contribute and aggravate to gender inequalities.

      Location

      Siegbahn Hall

      Campusmap

  • Plenary Session 6
    • 19 September 2008, 14:00-14:40

      Dynamics of a Masculine Field: Learning and Teaching

      On the Route to Gender and Diversity Mainstreaming in Higher Physics Education

      Monika Bessenrodt-Weberpals, Department Media Technology, Hamburg University of Applied Science

      Reflective coeducation in physics is an attempt to abolish gender stereotypes and to replace them with a positive view on female and male identity, respectively. In this approach teaching combines authentic experiences with activating cooperative learning. Topics in modern physics and in everyday life, e.g. environmental or biological examples, inspire female and male students alike to use fundamental physical concepts competently, to devise scientific experiments and models, and to apply their knowledge to everyday situations as well as to technical problems. This context-based learning experience is well adapted to physics students as well as to the needs of a  knowledge-based society. Furthermore, investigations prove that a temporary segregation of female and male students can have a positive effect on the women.

      Location

      Siegbahn Hall

      Campusmap